Playing with your kids
I was watching Supernanny last night. I really like that show. Initially when I watch, I wonder how in the heck a parent can let their children get so out of control. I mean, these parents really grow to resent their kids! They are MISERABLE!
Did you see the show last night? The laughing lady? Yeah, she was driving me batty!!! I could not believe that a simple trip to the drug store could be so completely out. of. control.
But as the show progresses, I sometimes feel a sense of guilt. Supernanny is very into schedules. Scheduled times to wake, eat, sleep, run errands and PLAY. I think she would be a bit appalled at my lack of a schedule.
Now I definitely believe in somewhat of a schedule, like for sleeping. I read once that the only time you can leave it up to a child as to how much sleep they get is when they are infants. I completely agree. Of course, I can't make my kids fall asleep, but I can definitely make sure my little one is in a cuddly and quiet bed for naptime, and all kids are tucked in bed at a reasonable hour. We have a neighbor with a second grader whom we see outside on walks at 9 (or later) at night! They were going in to eat dinner at 8 p.m. last night? And that neighbor complains that her daughter is a bear to get up in the morning. Is she serious!? (They are a little strange anyway, I should post a photo of their "political" signs in their yard. That is a whole post in itself....interesting...)
Anyway, what I really have a hard time with is a schedule for playtime. Supernanny advises parents to have scheduled times to sit down and play, or color, or do crafts... every day.
I do not play with my kids like that. Yes, we sometimes go on fun outings, yes, we play games sometimes, yes, I will go outside and play baseball or soccer once in a while. But no, not all the time. And no, I do not spend hours playing dolls, house, school, etc. etc. And I do not make up games for them to play. I leave that up to their own imagination.
Many times (most times), my kids play by themselves. Even during the day when my oldest is in school, my youngest plays by herself a lot. I guilt sometimes. Especially when I am doing something like blogging. But I also do a lot of other things like cleaning, laundry, yard work, bills, etc. And believe me, my house is far from perfect.
But, for some reason, my youngest Kallie is happiest when I am hard at work. When I am cleaning upstairs, she gathers up her blanket, a few toys and her drink and lays down in the doorway of each room as I clean it. She loves watching me and loves helping me. The other day, Kallie helped me pick up sticks in the front yard. She loved it!
And we also go run errands, or visit grandparents. So I am definitely not neglecting her. But I do not spend a lot of time sitting down and playing with her when we are just home during the day. My mom NEVER played with us (that was usually my Dad's job). And we turned out OK I think.
But Kallie has also learned to play so well by herself. Right now she has her Barbie and the prince doll and they are dancing together. I am not kidding, she will just hold these dolls and have them "dance" for HOURS.
So, what do you do? Do others really have scheduled "playtime"?

19 visitors to our world:
When I am at home, no. But, even before I started working, I never scheduled play time. I think it is an important skill for kids to learn to entertain themselves without the TV. I have had scheduled meal times and sleeping times. And I do play, but I have to say that I am not that great at that part. My MIL, who watches Jack Jack is much better at it than me, luckily :)
If it works for you, who cares?! I like to watch Super Nanny too, but she isn't perfect. What works for some doesn't work for others.
I have two grown daughters and no, I sure never scheduled play time...sometimes I think people go overboard with schedules.
Both of our daughters worked full time and went to college full time, and now both hold good jobs...so I don't think what we did with them was a failure.
I must say I read your blog, and it sure brings back some of the issues I went through...I am glad my kids are grown, but sure wish I had had the internet to talk to other people when they were young. I always questioned myself....
Irene, I couldn't agree with you more. I am not my child's playmate, however, I am around them constantly, redirecting and adding entertainment in my own way with humor. My kids know they are loved and they are safe.
I think the scheduling is absolutely necessary for out-of-control children and parents. It's the one way The Nanny can completely rock their world and change all the bad habits.
I'm sure life would have been a little easier if my kids had lived by the clock but I don't know if they'd be as well-adjusted or flexible as they are now.
Good ol' common sense trumps the experts everytime. That being said, those people on the show NEED schedules to get through the day.
Great post.
We don't have a scheduled playtime. Sometimes, Maddie is playing with her dolls, and asks us to play with her, and we do. We sometimes don't though, b/c I think it is important that she learn to entertain herself. There are times when i like to surprise her by taking her to the park/zoo/museum/whatever, just so we can play and have fun. Together. That's what works for us. And, sometimes, I think we are about halfway normal.
I think supernanny is great. But I also think this idea is over the top. Super nanny is a nanny, so it is her job and she gets paid to make sure the children she cares for get certain interactions. I don't believe that scheduled playtime is a interaction that needs to happen in everyday Stay-at-home parent households. I also believe that cleaning, gardening and watching mommy cook are wonderful interactions that happen naturally and enrich our children's lives more than we know.
In an ideal world, yes, scheduled playtime would be great. But we all live real lives. I think you're doing well if you can find fun and involve your kids in the day-to-day things that have to be done.
Hi Irene,
I don't think I ever had a set playtime when my kids were little but now that I am a grandma it's playtime all the time. :-) BTW, I love your photos on your sidebar. I looked at them and they are wonderful.
I hear you about schedules, but I'm betting that you hear your children when they talk to you...you don't have an earphone in your hear tuning them out. Your children are secure to know that you are available to them even if you are in the next room. The parents on Nanny last night were so removed from their children even though they were close to them in proximity.
Thanks for this! I watch Supernanny, too, but I'm a little behind in recordings so I haven't seen this one yet. I'm a lot like you. I'll do a puzzle or something once in a while, but I'm not doin scheduled play. She's got some good tips, but sometimes she goes a little overboard.
I can't even understand how the kids get that bad. The saddest part of the show has to be when they have on parents that just give up and don't care anymore.
Great post!
I have to admit, I have a schedule written on the refrigerator but it is more of a guide for myself and we don't follow it religiously but it does serve as a reminder for me. We have routines more than schedules around naptime, bathtime, bedtime, etc. but I also realize that flexibility is important. I do try to take my daughter outside to play everday after her nap and we play at the park, take a walk, collect acorns, etc. She is still pretty young so I do "play" with her a lot but she also plays by herself quite well when I am cooking, cleaning, etc. My son is older and every once in a while we "play" together building lincoln logs or something but he is very creative and good at entertaining himslef. I think it is all about balance and what works for your family. If it aint broke- don't fix it!
Scheduling every minute of every day seems like a joke to me. Life is not that structured and childhood most certainly shouldn't be either. Alexis and I do play, play, play though, when she wants to since she actually enjoys playing by herself after a day at daycare. I think it's a good balance, but we'll see how she turns out I guess.
Irene, I've thought exactly the same thing about Super Nanny. If you don't sit down and play dolls with your kids you're a bad mom and your kids will turn out bad? Puleeze! Mom NEVER once played with us! Also, my little one loves it, too when I clean. She follows me into every room and plays with whatever's in that room.
I love - LOVE - a kid that can play by themselves!!! All of my kids grew up knowing how to entertain themselves - it is the best gift I ever gave my kids!!!
Have a good weekend - Kellan
I read somewhere that a child that can play on it's own will become a creative person.
I too, do not "play" with my kids. I leave it to them. Sometimes I do feel guilty when the kids ask to play Barbies or what not. But, I make up for it, outdoors.
Great post. Lot to think about Irene.
I am with you 100%. Now I can feel less guilty knowing that I am not the only one.
I agree 100% too. I LOVE watching supernanny, but some of her stuff is just not realistic! That laughing woman drove me batty too. Sheesh. She needs to get a grip!
I play with my kids, but not every day, and not all day long. I want them to learn to use their imaginations, not to have to rely on guided play all the time. We have a routine of sorts, but nothing like her super regimented schedule.
Post a Comment